Pin
Whenever I’m juggling a packed schedule or feeding a crowd, I whip up these loaded beef and cheese sandwiches. There’s something about soft hoagie buns stuffed with seasoned beef in a creamy mushroom and cheddar sauce that always gets everyone reaching for seconds—and they’re simple to make, too.
One time I made these for friends during a football game and they were gone before we’d even found our seats. Now it’s what I turn to for easy guaranteed crowd-pleasing meals.
Must-Have Ingredients
- Cheddar cheese: shred sharp cheddar so it melts like a dream and has loads of flavor do it yourself for the best melt
- Salt and pepper to taste: fresh cracked black pepper boosts the whole thing don’t skip it
- Worcestershire sauce: gives everything a savory kick find one with anchovies for boldness
- Cream of mushroom soup: use a homemade pot if time allows or grab a quality canned version for convenience
- Garlic: mince it up because that garlicky bite makes sandwiches great
- Green bell pepper: chop it for color a bit of sweet crunch and freshness
- Montreal steak spice: packs a punch and keeps things extra tasty watch the salt in some brands
- Onion: dice it super fine for sweetness and flavor layers go for fresh
- Ground beef: classic eighty twenty has the flavor lean works too if you’re watching grease
- Avocado oil or another oil you have: helps brown everything evenly with no sticking light flavor is best
- Hoagie rolls: grab sturdy soft rolls so they can handle all that saucy filling
Simple Instructions
- Fill the Rolls:
- Scoop the cheesy beef mixture into your hoagie buns overfill if you want a hearty bite eat before it cools so everything stays gooey and the bread crisp
- Add the Cheese:
- Once you kill the heat, stir in a heap of cheddar until it melts all the way now the mix turns extra rich
- Pour In the Sauce:
- Add the cream of mushroom soup and a good splash of Worcestershire stir again then shake in salt and pepper simmer a bit until everything’s thickened and creamy
- Dump in Peppers & Garlic:
- Now, stir in those chopped peppers and minced garlic cook a few minutes so the garlic smells awesome and peppers just soften
- Season Everything:
- Shower the beef and onions with Montreal steak spice stir real well so every bite tastes great
- Brown Beef & Onion:
- Add your ground beef and onion cook it up seven to ten minutes until beef is browned and lots of flavor shows on the onions
- Warm Up the Skillet:
- Heat two spoonfuls of oil in your big skillet on medium-high so beef and onion won’t stick and get a nice little crust
Pin
Montreal steak spice is my not so secret special touch. When I first tossed it in, my dad said it tasted just like his favorite burger. Now, he won’t let me make these any other way. Every batch reminds me of lazy Sundays when my whole family hung out in the kitchen waiting for the first sandwich to hit the plate.
Storing Leftovers
If you’ve got extra filling, stash it in a sealed container in the fridge for up to three days. Heat it slow on the stove or zap in the microwave. If it thickens, just add a splash of milk. Always set up fresh sandwiches so the bread doesn’t get soggy.
Ways to Swap Ingredients
If you’re up for switching it up, try ground turkey or chicken to lighten things. Swap in mozzarella or provolone for a new cheese twist. Go homemade on the mushroom soup for extra flavor, but canned is totally fine if you’re short on time.
Pin
What To Pair With
Serve these sandwiches with a handful of crunchy chips a fresh garden salad or tomato soup For a heartier spread add roasted veggies or crispy oven fries Kids love carrot sticks on the side for fast weeknight dinners
FAQs About the Recipe
- → What are easy ways to get the beef extra creamy?
Just stir in a splash or two of milk to the filling if you want it smoother before you build your sandwiches.
- → Which cheese should I use if I want the best melt?
Sharp cheddar is awesome because it melts perfectly and tastes bold. Monterey Jack or mozzarella make it milder, if you like that.
- → Can I switch up the bread base?
You sure can. French rolls, ciabatta, or even half a soft baguette work if you don't have hoagie rolls on hand.
- → What veggies can I add to change things up?
Totally! Toss in cooked mushrooms, roasted red peppers, or even sliced jalapeños for more crunch or heat.
- → How do I make this whole thing hotter?
Mix a spoonful of your go-to hot sauce or some pickled jalapeño slices in with the beef to fire up the flavor.
- → Any tips on serving these sandwiches?
They're awesome when you eat them warm right from the pan, but pairing them with some soup or a crisp side salad works great too.