Pin
Strawberry Shortcake Sugar Cookies are my pick-me-up when winter days get long. They’re the secret to jazzing up any holiday cookie box, too. A regular sugar cookie steps up its game with a pretty glaze and a crunchy coating of strawberry shortcake crumbs. Every nibble tastes just like the dreamy top layer of a strawberry shortcake—all tucked into one fun cookie.
These popped up after my niece wished for something festive and pink on Valentine’s Day. Lately, I bring them to birthday parties or picnics—the smiles are always worth it when people spot them.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Strawberry shortcake crumbs: sweet crunchy pieces for topping, real dried strawberry bits make it all pop
- Pink food coloring: brightens things up, gel colors keep your glaze vivid without thinning it
- Milk: helps loosen the glaze just enough for easy drizzling, whole milk means a creamier icing
- Confectioner's sugar: smooths out the glaze, sifting gets rid of stubborn lumps
- Baking powder: gives your cookie lift and perfect texture, check it’s still good before you use it
- Salt: brings out the sweet notes, sea salt leaves everything tasting pure
- All-purpose flour: makes the base chewy not tough, sift for fluffiness
- Vanilla extract: brings a warm perfume, use real vanilla if you can
- Large eggs: keep the dough together and make it moist, the fresher the better
- Granulated sugar: sweetens and creates the right spread, choose the fine kind to blend in smooth
- Softened butter: gives that soft bite and rich flavor, quality matters here
Easy Instructions
- Decorate and Finish
- Zigzag both pink and white glazes over the tops of your cooled cookies. I love using a sandwich bag with the tip cut. Right after, toss on the strawberry crumbs while the glaze is still wet so they really stick. Give them some time to set before stacking or packing up as gifts.
- Make Glaze and Color
- Mix milk into the powdered sugar till you get a pourable paste. Split the glaze in two bowls—add a tiny drop of pink coloring to one for a cute pastel color. Gel food color will give you the best pink.
- Bake and Cool
- Slide the tray into a 350 oven and bake for about ten minutes. You want the edges barely golden, not brown. Let them rest on the baking tray for two minutes, then pop them on a cooling rack so they don't steam up.
- Shape and Flatten Dough
- Grab a spoonful of dough and roll it into a ball. Put them on a parchment-lined tray, then press down each one with a glass so they’re just over a quarter inch thick. This keeps them baking nice and even.
- Combine Dry Ingredients
- Sift flour, salt, and baking powder directly over the butter mixture. Mix gently until just combined so the cookies come out soft, not rubbery.
- Add Eggs and Vanilla
- Beat in the eggs one by one so everything’s blended. Pour in the vanilla and keep mixing; it should start to smell sweet and cozy.
- Cream the Butter and Sugar
- Whip up softened butter and sugar with a mixer for at least four minutes on medium. You’re aiming for a light, fluffy base—this makes your cookies extra tender.
Pin
The best bit? Swirling that first pink stripe of glaze and scattering crumbs. I’ll never forget the day I made them with my little cousins; everyone wanted to run the drizzle bag and the kitchen turned into a pink frosting party.
Storage Know-How
Stash the cookies in a single layer in a sealed container at room temp and they’ll taste great for up to four days. Parchment between layers keeps things tidy if you stack them. Freeze plain cookies if you want them to last longer; just frost after thawing for that fresh bite.
Easy Ingredient Swaps
Go with almond instead of vanilla if you like a hint of nuttiness. Swap in lactose-free butter and non-dairy milk—no one will tell. For the topping, mix crushed freeze-dried strawberries and a bit of vanilla cookie if you can’t find the shortcake crumbs.
Fun Ways to Serve
Serve them at baby showers or with afternoon tea—they’ll steal the show. They’re especially tasty next to a bowl of ripe strawberries. Hosting a kid’s party? Let the kids go wild with drizzling and toppings—the mess is part of the fun.
Pin
A Bit of Tradition
Did you know strawberry shortcake’s been a big deal in American homes since the 1840s, often marking special occasions? These cookies mash up all that classic flavor in a treat you can grab and go. Perfect for busy get-togethers.
FAQs About the Recipe
- → What's the trick for soft and fluffy cookies?
Get your butter nice and soft, mix it well with sugar until it's airy, and pull the cookies from the oven before they turn golden.
- → Is it fine if I just buy shortcake crumbs?
Sure, store-bought makes things quicker, but fresh, homemade crumbs have more flavor and extra crunch.
- → Should cookies be cool before I add the glaze?
Definitely let them cool down or the glaze won’t stay put—it’ll just drip off and make a mess.
- → What’s a simple way to drizzle the glaze?
Grab a cheap piping bag, or snip a small corner off a sandwich bag to easily zig-zag glaze over the tops.
- → How do I keep the cookies fresh?
Once your glaze is dry, tuck cookies into a sealed container to keep them tasting great for several days.
- → Can I skip food coloring?
Yep, it’s totally up to you—drop it or tint naturally if you want something more wholesome-looking.