Pin
Every bite of these caramel-packed chocolate chip cookies feels like a warm hug. They're the kind of treat you'll turn to on slow weekends or big celebrations. Each one bursts open with melted chocolate and gooey caramel, holding onto a pillowy soft center and a touch of crunch on the edges. You only need a big bowl which makes cleanup super quick, and you can stash the dough in the fridge or freezer for sudden sweet cravings.
The first time I made these for a buddy’s birthday, I just wanted something bold and dripping with chocolate and caramel. That went over so well that now the family always requests them at gatherings.
Crave-worthy Ingredients
- Soft caramels: pop them into the middle or slice for the tops, Werther’s work perfectly since they melt just the right amount
- Semi-sweet chocolate chips: splurge on the good stuff so every chunk oozes chocolate in every cookie
- Salted butter: gives a deep, salty richness—make sure to melt it then let it cool off first so everything mixes smoothly
- Brown sugar: locks in moisture for extra chew and brings tasty caramel notes—go for a softer variety
- Granulated sugar: helps make the cookies spread out just enough and balances the sweetness—avoid anything too gritty
- Large eggs: keep things fluffy and hold everything together—fresh ones are best
- Vanilla extract: boosts the overall flavor—real vanilla makes them smell amazing
- All-purpose flour: builds the cookie base—remember to spoon and level so things aren’t too heavy
- Baking powder: helps them rise—for the puffiest cookies, use one that’s still fresh
- Baking soda: adds chew and color—double check it's still good by dropping a bit in vinegar to see if it fizzes
- Salt: rounds out the flavors—a fine sea salt sprinkles in evenly
Simple Steps to Bake
- Cool and Snack:
- Let cookies chill out right on the pan so they can finish setting up. Dig in while they’re warm for dreamy caramel or let them cool all the way if you want to store some for later.
- Bake the Cookies:
- Crank the oven up to 365°F and get your trays ready with parchment or silicone sheets. Place each stuffed dough ball spaced out on the tray. Bake for about 10 to 12 minutes until the edges look golden and the middle’s still a touch wobbly. Want perfect round cookies? Grab a round cutter and swirl it around while they’re hot for neat edges.
- Create Cookie Balls:
- Scoop big 90-gram chunks of dough for that bakery-style look. Flatten each one out, then tuck a whole caramel in the center and seal it tight. Top each ball with a few caramel slivers and extra chips for good measure.
- Chill the Dough:
- Pop the bowl in the fridge or freezer for about 20 minutes. The dough needs to firm up so the cookies stay thick and chewy out of the oven.
- Add Chocolate Chips:
- Gently fold in the chocolate chips last. That keeps them in big puddles instead of breaking up.
- Add the Dry Stuff:
- Dump in the flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Lightly mix with a wooden spoon or spatula. Don’t sweat if it looks crumbly at first—just keep going until it comes together.
- Add Vanilla and Eggs:
- Drop in the eggs and vanilla and mix really well for half a minute or more until glossy and thick. This makes for even cookies every time.
- Mix the Wet Stuff:
- In your big bowl, whisk the melted (but not hot) butter with both sugars until totally smooth. Make sure there aren’t any little lumps left.
- Cut Up the Caramels:
- Start by unwrapping all the caramels. Pick out 15 to use whole for stuffing, then cut the rest into small pieces for pressing into the tops. Keeping the sizes the same helps them melt just right.
Pin
Caramel steals the show here. The very first time I jammed whole caramels inside cookie dough, everyone could smell the magic. Folks hovered near the oven just waiting to grab them warm from the tray.
How to Store
Once cookies are cool, tuck them into an airtight container and keep on the counter for four to five days. Want them super soft? The fridge will help with that. To get gooey caramel centers again, just zap them in the microwave for a few seconds or put them back in a low oven till soft and warm.
Swapping Ingredients
No salted butter? Unsalted plus a smidge more salt does the trick. You can go bold with dark chocolate chips if you want a deeper chocolate flavor. If Werther’s aren’t around, pick another brand of soft caramels that don’t get hard in the oven. For a little crunch, mix in pecans or walnuts during the chocolate chip step.
Fun Ways to Serve
These cookies are awesome all by themselves, but they’re even better with vanilla ice cream on the side. Try them with a mug of coffee or cold milk for the best snack. When you want to be extra, pour on some melted caramel and sprinkle with sea salt before serving.
Pin
Story Behind the Classic
This is the old-school chocolate chip cookie all dressed up with caramel. It’s a playful switch that’s perfect for bake sales or swapping at holiday parties. Every batch takes me right back to my grandma’s kitchen, where we tried out crazy new add-ins and made every family favorite our own.
FAQs About the Recipe
- → How can you make sure cookies stay chewy and soft?
Mix in both brown and white sugar plus melted butter, and pull the cookies out before they look totally set. Don't move them off the pan till they're fully cool to keep the centers super tender.
- → Is it cool to mix up what kind of chocolate chips you use?
Oh, for sure! If you're bored of semi-sweet, grab milk, dark, or even some white chocolate for something different.
- → What's the best move for keeping leftover cookies good?
Seal them up tight in a container right on the counter and they'll be tasty for up to five days, or pop in the fridge to keep them even longer.
- → How do you warm up cookies so they’re soft again?
Heat them fast in a microwave or let them sit in a low oven to get that gooey caramel and soft bite back.
- → Can you freeze this dough?
Definitely—just scoop out the dough, freeze the balls until they're solid, then stash them in a container or bag. You can bake straight from frozen whenever you want some cookies.
- → Which caramel works best for stuffing inside?
Grab some soft, individually wrapped caramels. They're easy to tuck in and melt down for that perfect gooey middle—no hassle at all.