Pin
I always reach for these easy parfaits when I've gotta whip up dessert for unexpected company. They're a perfect mix of smooth cheesecake, crumbly graham crackers, and a sweet cherry pop on top. The look of pretty layers in their own cups fools everyone into thinking I went all out—even though it's basically a five-minute fix.
The first time I made these was when my oven completely quit right before a surprise birthday. Folks couldn't believe how good they were; someone asked for how to make them before they even finished eating! Now it's a must-have at family parties.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Cherry pie filling: Pops of color and bright fruity sweetness. Go for the good stuff so it really shines
- Vanilla extract: Brings out all the other flavors. Real extract gives the best boost
- Lemon juice: Thickens things up naturally and adds a zippy kick to cut the sweet
- Sweetened condensed milk: Adds plenty of sweetness and makes the filling rich and thick without extra sugar
- Cream cheese: This is the creamy heart of the filling. Let it get soft so everything blends smooth
- Butter: Melts in for a rich taste and binds the crumbs. Unsalted is best so you can control the saltiness
- Granulated sugar: Gives just the right touch of sweetness in the crumb base
- Graham cracker crumbs: Crunchy, classic base—freshly crushed is tastier
Simple Steps to Build It
- Finish With More Cherries:
- Spoon any cherry filling you saved on top of each parfait. Sprinkle any crumbs you still have for extra crunch and color. Looks fancy, tastes even better.
- Load Up Second Cheesecake Layer:
- Spread the last of the creamy mix on top of every cup. Do your best to keep those pretty layers—go slow if you need.
- Pop Another Graham Layer:
- Spoon more crumbs (about 2 tablespoons) over the cherry filling. Layering is what makes these so fun to eat.
- Pour On the Cherry:**
- Scoop half your cherry filling over the cheesecake in all six cups. Grab both cherry fruit and that shiny gel.
- Layer the First Filling:
- Drop 3 tablespoons of your cheesecake mixture in each cup, even it out a bit. You want a smooth layer here.
- Add Graham Cracker Base:
- Put 2 tablespoons of your crumb mix into the bottom of six cups. Press lightly with the back of a spoon—just enough so it stays put but isn't packed too tight.
- Mix Cheesecake Filling:
- Beat softened cream cheese until it's super smooth—just a couple of minutes should do. Slowly add condensed milk while mixing to keep it silky. When it looks thick but still pours, you're good.
- Finish Mixing the Filling:
- Pour in lemon juice and vanilla, mix well. You'll see the lemon makes things thick and creamy while giving a tiny tangy kick.
Pin
Cream cheese is the real MVP here. Letting it chill out and fully soften before beating gives the filling that ultra-smooth vibe. Grandma always said lumps in cheesecake are a dealbreaker, and honestly—she was right. It's the easiest trick for dreamy texture.
Best Make-Ahead Advice
Honestly, these get even better if you let them hang out in the fridge for a while. Everything blends together so the flavors pop. Make them a couple hours or even a full day in advance. The crumbs might get a bit softer, but you'll still get nice texture against all that creaminess.
Fun Ways to Switch It Up
If you're not into cherries, try blueberries for a fresh look and mellow flavor. Slice up peaches and add a pinch of cinnamon for a twist. Super into citrus? Lemon filling is tangy and refreshing, especially when it's hot outside. Go homemade on the fruit if you want less sweet and more grown-up.
Pin
How to Serve It Up
They're awesome on their own, but for festive nights, add whipped cream and a sprig of mint. Want to make it extra special? Use glass cups or wine glasses to really show off those layers. Pair with coffee or a sweet sip after dinner. Or go wild with a DIY topping bar—set out whipped cream, chocolate shreds, and all kinds of fruit, and let everyone build their own.
Keep Them Fresh
Parfaits last great in the fridge for three days if you cover them well. Actually, they taste even better the second day. Skip the freezer though—the filling won't be the same after thawing. If you wanna get way ahead, prep the pieces, then put it all together a day before you need them.
FAQs About the Recipe
- → Is there another topping I can swap for cherries?
Of course! Try blueberry, peach, lemon, or any fruit filling you like for your own spin.
- → What’s the fridge life for these parfaits?
Keep them covered in the fridge and they’ll taste great for about three days.
- → I don’t have graham crackers—what else works for crumbs?
No worries! Try crushed Oreos, digestives, or whatever cookies you’re into for a fun change.
- → How can I whip up some cream for the top?
Simply beat cold heavy cream with sugar and a splash of vanilla until it holds soft peaks.
- → If I’m out of lemon juice, what should I use?
Squeeze in some lime juice instead. It’s just as tart and helps set up the filling.