Pin
This hearty chicken and loaded baked potato casserole pulls together all my favorite things about relaxed family meals: crispy beefy bacon, soft juicy chicken, plenty of gooey cheese all layered on top of rich buttery potatoes. What once started as a throw-together meal with odds and ends has earned top spot for those times we want something comfy but easy to put together.
Every time I whip it up, it vanishes by the end of the party. My partner actually asks for it anytime there’s a big game on TV.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Whole milk: keeps the sauce luscious. Always go full fat for smoothness.
- Salt and black pepper: pulls all the flavors together. Sea salt and fresh cracked pepper bring extra flavor.
- Real beef bacon bits: adds that crunchy, savory kick. Double check you’re not buying fake ones!
- Fresh green onions: give it freshness and color. Pick bunches with the greenest tops.
- Sharp cheddar cheese: melts perfectly and brings bite. Aged is even better—it’s bolder and smoother.
- Full fat sour cream: makes things tangy and rich. Using the freshest stuff gives the most flavor.
- Rotisserie chicken: super easy, just shred it up for sweetness and moisture. Go for a hot one if you can.
- Russet potatoes: look for big, firm ones with smooth skin. Bake and cool before cubing for the best base.
Easy-To-Follow Instructions
- Get That Crunchy Top:
- Pop off the foil and let it bake 5-10 more minutes until you see bubbly golden cheese. Give it a few minutes out of the oven so everything firms up before scooping.
- Pop It In The Oven:
- Cover nice and snug with foil. Bake at 350°F for around 35-40 minutes. Peek to make sure it’s bubbling all the way through.
- Stack Up More Layers:
- Toss on the last of your potatoes, then add the rest of the chicken, green onions, cheddar, cream mix, and beefy bacon for a double-decker taste.
- Add the Flavor Punch:
- Sprinkle on the green onions, cheddar, and beef bacon bits. Don’t forget a pinch of salt and pepper!
- Pour On The Creamy Stuff:
- Mix up the milk and sour cream until it’s totally smooth. No lumps! Drizzle about half of it evenly over your base.
- Layer In The Chicken:
- Scatter half your chicken right over the potatoes. Make sure you even out any big hunks.
- Line That Dish With Potatoes:
- Lay half your potato cubes in a buttered 9x13 inch pan. Try to spread them so every serve has a solid foundation.
- Bake and Dice Potatoes:
- Bake those russets until soft inside. Let cool, then chop into neat little cubes. That way each spoonful gets a splash of sauce.
Pin
That smell of bubbling cheese and beef bacon always brings my kid running, begging for his piece. He’s wild about the crispy potato edges every single time.
How To Store
Once it’s cooled down, slice the casserole and move pieces into airtight containers. It’ll chill out in the fridge for about three days. Want it to last longer? Wrap slices up and freeze for a couple months. Warm back up in the oven on low—helps it stay soft and creamy.
Swaps & Alternatives
For a little sweetness, try sweet potatoes. No beef bacon? Crispy turkey bacon or classic bacon strips are tasty stand-ins. Want more veggies? Fold in some cooked corn or broccoli. Change up the cheese and try Monterey Jack or Gruyere for a twist.
How To Serve
I like to dish this up with a simple salad to lighten things. Add a spoonful of sour cream or a splash of hot sauce for extra yum. Steamed broccoli or roasted green beans work great next to it. We always finish with crunchy apple slices to bring some freshness.
Pin
Where This Classic Comes From
Dishes like this with spuds, cheddar, bacon, and sour cream started as Midwestern favorites. Adding chicken makes it the main event instead of just a side. For decades, families have been using casseroles like this to stretch out simple food into big filling meals.
FAQs About the Recipe
- → What's the trick for soft potatoes inside?
Roast the russets whole. Once they're fork-tender, dice them up and then toss into your bake. That keeps them pillowy soft.
- → Can chicken breast replace rotisserie?
Yep. Go with any cooked chicken breast or thigh, shredded or cubed—you'll get the same homey taste and feel.
- → Any advice for cheesy golden tops?
Take the foil off for the last 5–10 minutes so the top can get that crunchy-browned look and a bit of bacon crisp.
- → Want to bump up cheese flavor?
Aged cheddar’s my pick, but mixing in Gouda or Monterey Jack will give you extra oomph.
- → How do you keep leftovers fresh?
Let it cool first then seal it in the fridge (airtight box works best). Heat it up gently so it stays creamy for up to three days.
- → Is it okay to prep this a day in advance?
Definitely. Just build it, stash in the fridge for up to 24 hours, then pop in the oven when you want. Tastes extra fresh that way.