Pin
Ready in no time, this rich and cozy cottage cheese alfredo delivers that creamy comfort you crave. Each bite feels indulgent, but the sauce is way lighter than the classic versions. With loads of protein and easy on the prep, it brings all that good old flavor with a better-for-you twist.
After a rough day, I threw everything together and was surprised how cottage cheese just melted away in the sauce. It's now my first choice any time I want that yummy creamy vibe without the extra hassle.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Black pepper: Gives a gentle punch at the end, especially good if you crack it fresh before serving
- Salt: Brightens up the flavors—taste the finished sauce and tweak as you go
- Oregano: Adds a warm herbal layer; check that your dried herbs are still green, not gray
- Basil: Brings that familiar Italian note—crush leaves between your hands for a boost of aroma
- Garlic powder: For that must-have garlicky smell; grab a fine powder so it mixes in smoothly
- Cornstarch: Makes the sauce thick and shiny, so it sticks to every noodle; sift if lumpy
- Parmesan cheese: Freshly shredded melts best for sharp, gooey results; skip the canned stuff
- Whole milk: Loosens up the sauce and adds richness, just make sure it's fresh and not about to spoil
- Cottage cheese: Small-curd and full-fat gives that lusciously smooth base, but low-fat will work if you want lighter
- Pasta: Go with short shapes—they grab more sauce and are extra comforting
Simple How-Tos
- Serve and Sprinkle:
- Dish it up into bowls and finish with more parmesan, some fresh parsley, and a little extra black pepper. Jump in while it's hot and creamy.
- Mix Sauce and Pasta Together:
- Drop your cooked noodles into the warm pan. Toss until they're all wrapped up in sauce. Taste and add salt or pepper if you need.
- Warm Everything Up:
- Pour that blended goodness into a big skillet. Cook low and slow for about five minutes, stirring to stop the dairy from burning, until it's thick and glossy.
- Blend Up the Sauce:
- Dump cottage cheese, parmesan, milk, cornstarch, garlic powder, basil, and oregano into your blender. Blitz everything until totally smooth—at least a full minute. Scrape and blend again if you need.
- Boil the Pasta:
- Fill a large pot with salted water and get it to a rolling boil. Add your pasta. Cook till it’s how you like. Drain and try not to rinse.
Pin
The satin-smooth sauce is my favorite thing—the cottage cheese disappears and nobody knows it's there. One time, my son flipped out when he found out the secret, and now it’s all he wants for dinner.
Handy Storage
Stash any extras in a container with a good lid and keep them in the fridge up to three days. The sauce will get thicker as it chills, so pour in a splash of milk while warming it up. Gently reheat on the stove or pop it in the microwave when you're hungry later.
Swap Suggestions
Out of whole milk? Try two percent if you want it lighter. Boost the flavor by tossing in chopped spinach or sun-dried tomatoes. Plant milk works too—just don't use one that's sweet or tastes strong. If you love true Italian cheese, ask for Parmigiano Reggiano at the cheese shop.
Easy Sides & Add-Ons
This dish is awesome with a crisp salad or warm garlicky bread. Want to make it a meal? Toss in some grilled chicken, pan-roasted veggies, or mushrooms. A little bit of lemon zest on top brightens it right up.
Pin
FAQs About the Recipe
- → Is it okay to swap in low-fat cottage cheese?
Totally, though you’ll get the creamiest results if you stick to whole milk cottage cheese.
- → Which shapes of pasta should I try?
Penne, linguine, or fettuccine are great picks, but whatever pasta you like will soak up the sauce just fine.
- → What’s the trick for gluten-free eats?
Just grab your favorite gluten-free pasta and you’re good to go.
- → What can I toss in for extra flavor or protein?
Try some cooked shrimp, chicken, fresh peas, or even spinach for a tasty boost.
- → How can I make the sauce super silky?
Blend your cottage cheese mix until it’s totally smooth before you warm it up.