Pin
Nothing beats a homemade chicken pot pie for true comfort food! I've whipped up this dish countless times over the years, and it always brings everyone to the table eagerly. When that buttery, flaky crust meets the creamy chicken mixture inside, you get that warm, cozy feeling that only real comfort cooking can give you.
I first threw this pot pie together during a brutal cold snap when we couldn't leave the house for several days. The smell wrapped our home in coziness, and now my kids beg for it as their weekend treat regularly.
What You'll Need
- For the crust part:
- All purpose flour: Forms the base that gives you that wonderful flakiness
- Sugar: Brings a hint of sweetness that works against the savory stuffing
- Cold unsalted butter: The key to getting those delicious flaky bits
- Buttermilk: Makes the crust soft with a slight tang
- Cold water: Pulls the dough together without making it tough
- Egg wash: Gives you that gorgeous golden top
- For what goes inside:
- Unsalted butter: Makes a tasty base for your sauce
- Onion, carrots, and celery: The flavor foundation of everything good
- Fresh garlic: Brings a punch that powder just can't match
- Flour: Makes your filling nice and thick
- Fresh herbs: Take this from basic to amazing
- Chicken broth: Adds rich, meaty flavor to the sauce
- Heavy cream: Makes everything deliciously creamy
- Shredded chicken or turkey: Turns this into a filling meal
- Frozen peas: Add pretty color, a bit of sweet, and nice texture
Cooking Walkthrough
- First, tackle the crust:
- Mix your dry stuff in a big bowl, then work in the cold butter chunks by smashing them into thin layers with the flour mix. This creates those amazing flaky bits everyone loves. Let it chill for 15 minutes to keep the butter cold, then splash in buttermilk and shape into two flat circles before cooling in the fridge.
- Next, cook up the filling:
- Drop butter in a big pan over medium-high heat, toss in the veggies and cook till they're soft, around 5 to 7 minutes. Don't brown them, just soften. Make your sauce by stirring in flour and spices then adding the wet ingredients slowly, making sure to stir out any lumps. This careful mixing keeps your sauce smooth. Let it bubble till thick, then stir in your chicken and peas.
- Put it all together:
- Roll one chilled dough circle into a 12-inch round about 1/4 inch thick on a floured counter. Getting the right thickness matters a lot - too skinny and it'll break, too fat and it won't cook right. Lay it carefully in your pie dish and pour in your filling. Roll the second circle and place it on top, then trim and pinch the edges together however you like.
- Cook it till it's gorgeous:
- Brush beaten egg on top to make it shiny and golden. Cut a few small holes in the top so steam can escape while it cooks. These holes stop your filling from bubbling over and making your oven messy. Bake at 400°F for 45 minutes, using something to cover the edges so they don't burn.
Pin
The game-changer in this dish is definitely fresh thyme. I grow mine at home, and when it hits that hot filling, the smell takes me back to cooking with my grandma, who showed me how to make crust when I was barely tall enough to see over the counter. She always told me that taking your time was the hidden ingredient in every good pie.
Prep It Early
This pie works great for planning ahead. You can cook the filling up to two days before and keep it in the fridge. The dough can also be made ahead and kept cold for up to three days or frozen for up to three months. When you're ready to bake, just put everything together and add about 5 to 10 extra minutes of cooking time if your stuff is cold from the fridge.
Switch It Up
You can change this recipe in so many ways. Try turkey after Thanksgiving or leftover ham for something different. If you don't eat meat, just throw in more veggies like mushrooms, potatoes, and green beans, plus extra seasoning. Don't do dairy? Coconut cream works instead of heavy cream for a tasty twist. You can even use gluten-free flour for both parts, though it might feel a bit different in your mouth.
Pin
What to Eat With It
Pair this pie with a basic green salad with light dressing to balance out how rich it is. For a really cozy meal, add some cranberry sauce on the side - that sweet-tart flavor goes amazingly with the savory pie. Having guests over? Make mini versions in small dishes for a fancy look that also saves serving time.
Where Chicken Pot Pie Came From
People have been eating pot pies for hundreds of years, with versions showing up in ancient Roman cooking and medieval Europe. What we call pot pie today came from meat pies that English folks brought to America. Back then, these pies were a smart way to stretch leftover meat to feed more people. The mix of chicken, veggies, and gravy in a pastry shell became super popular in the American South and Pennsylvania Dutch areas, where folks really know their comfort food.
FAQs About the Recipe
- → Is it okay to use store-bought chicken for this pot pie?
You bet! Store-bought rotisserie chicken works wonderfully here. It cuts down on cooking time and makes things easier while still tasting amazing.
- → Can I make this ahead and freeze it?
For sure! Just put the pie together, wrap it up good, and pop it in the freezer. When you're hungry, cook it frozen, just add about 10-15 minutes to your baking time.
- → Will pre-made crust work for this recipe?
It sure will! Grabbing ready-made crust saves time. But if you've got a few extra minutes, making your own gives you that extra-special taste and flakiness.
- → What other veggies can I throw in?
You can toss in or swap out with stuff like mushrooms, sweet corn, chopped green beans, or chunky potatoes, based on what you like or what's fresh right now.
- → How do I keep the edges from getting too dark?
Grab a pie shield or just wrap some foil around the edges if they start getting too brown while it's in the oven.